7 Ways to Create New Holiday Traditions That Fit the Family You Have Now
There’s a moment, usually somewhere between pulling out the good dishes and counting the chairs, when it hits you. The table doesn’t look the way it used to. It may be time to try 7 ways to create new holiday traditions that fit the family you have now.
Maybe the kids are grown and spread across three time zones. Maybe this is their year with the in-laws. Maybe there’s a new partner at the table you’re still getting to know. Or a grand baby in a high chair, or a chair that’s empty for a reason that still stings. Maybe one of your grown kids has moved back home. Maybe the holiday you pictured as a reunion looks a lot like a regular Tuesday.
However it happened, your family has taken a new shape. And the holidays, which are built on repeating what we’ve always done, have a way of making that change impossible to ignore.
For us, we’ve lost a number of mainstays at our table. Grandparents no longer with us. Kids who live across the country and lament how close together the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays are. Two cross-country flights in a month can feel like a big deal. The biggest change is who may be sitting in the chairs, but there also may be a big change in the menu, too. Vegan guests, gluten-free, and so on.

Here’s what I’ve come to believe. When your family changes shape, your holidays get to change shape too. Not as a consolation prize. As a chance to build something that actually fits the life you’re living now. It doesn’t do any good to lament what is no more. A better way to think of the holidays is gratitude for what was, and acceptance, even excitement, over what can be.
You’re not the only one whose holidays look different
If this season feels a little off, you’re in very good company.
In a recent survey of empty nesters, just over half expected their children to come home for the holidays. And those kids traveled an average of nearly 600 miles to get there. More than a third of the parents said the house feels too still now. About as many said they get nostalgic for when their kids were young.
And “empty nest” doesn’t mean what it used to. As the American Psychological Association pointed out this fall, many families go through a partial or delayed empty nest, with grown children leaving, coming back for a stretch, and leaving again. So your family’s shape may not only be different this year. It may keep shifting.
Add in divorce, remarriage, blended families, aging parents, new grandchildren, and the people we’ve lost, and it’s clear that very few of us are celebrating the holidays we grew up with. We’re just not always saying so out loud.
Why the holidays make the change feel bigger
Most of the year, a changing family shows up in small ways. A smaller grocery list. Fewer shoes by the door. Texts instead of Sunday dinners.
The holidays are different. They’re built on repetition: same recipes, same seats, same stories, same order of events. That’s what makes them comforting. It’s also what makes any change stand out. When one piece is missing or rearranged, we notice it against years of memories.
There’s also the weight of the role we’ve played. Many of us spent decades as the one who made the holiday happen. The planner, the cook, the keeper of traditions. When the people we did it for scatter or change, it can feel like we’ve lost a job, not only a gathering.
That’s real, and it’s worth acknowledging. But it’s not the whole story.
7 ways to let your holidays take a new shape
1. Say out loud what’s changed
Before you plan anything, name what’s different this year. Say it to your partner, a friend, or a notebook. “The boys won’t be home until Saturday.” “This is our first holiday without Grandma.” “I’m hosting fewer people, and it feels strange.”
It sounds small. It isn’t. When we don’t name a change, we tend to spend the whole day comparing it with the old version and wondering why we feel off. Naming it lets you plan for the holiday you actually have, not the one you remember.
2. Keep the one tradition that matters most
You don’t have to keep every tradition alive to keep the holiday meaningful. Ask yourself this: If I could only keep one thing from the way we’ve always done the holidays, what would it be?
Maybe it’s the pie. Maybe it’s the walk after dinner, or going around the table to say what you’re grateful for. Keep that one, and give yourself permission to let the rest be flexible.
If you’d like a simple way to sort what stays and what goes, my free guide Your Simple Season walks you through it. And if you followed my 5 do-ahead steps for holiday planning in October, you’re already halfway there.
3. Move the date
Who says Thanksgiving has to happen on Thursday? If your grown kids are splitting time between your house and their partner’s family, or working through the holiday, the most generous thing you can offer might be a different day.
A Thanksgiving Saturday or a Sunday dinner in December takes the pressure off everyone, including you. Nobody has to race between two tables, and you get your people relaxed instead of rushed. Gratitude doesn’t check the calendar.

4. Make room for the new people
New shapes often come with new people. A son’s girlfriend. A daughter-in-law. A partner’s kids. A grand baby. A friend who has nowhere else to go. They’re walking into traditions they don’t know and inside jokes they weren’t there for.
Make it easy for them to belong. Ask what they usually eat on the holiday and add one of their dishes to the table. Give them a job. Tell the story behind a tradition instead of assuming they’ll catch on. The best way to keep your family close as it grows is to make sure the newcomers feel like part of it, not guests at it.
5. Host a grown-up Friendsgiving
Friendsgiving isn’t only for twenty-somethings. Right now it’s a mostly young tradition. One 2026 holiday survey found 52% of Gen Z plan a Friendsgiving this year, compared with just 10% of adults 60 and older. That’s exactly why it’s worth trying. Many of us have friends in the same spot: kids far away, family scattered, a holiday weekend that feels a little long.
Keep it simple. Make it a potluck. Pick a night the week before or after the holiday. Invite the neighbor whose kids live overseas and the friend who just moved to town. A lot of people want a place at a table. They’re just waiting for someone to set it.
If you’re the guest this year, I rounded up easy hostess gifts in my Holiday Gift Guide.
6. Start a tradition that isn’t dinner
Some families are trading the big meal for something new entirely, like volunteering, an outdoor hike, or a game night at home. In another survey, 41% of people said they actually prefer creating new traditions over following old ones.
A few ideas to try:
- A morning walk or a local turkey trot, then leftovers on the couch
- Brunch instead of dinner, so the afternoon stays open
- A movie at the theater on the holiday itself
- A drive to see the first holiday lights of the season
- A video call where everyone shares one good thing from their year
- Using the day to prepare treats for elderly neighbors for distribution that week
New traditions don’t have to feel like a replacement. Give them two or three years, and they become the thing everyone asks about.

7. Decide what’s yours to carry
Last week in Thursday Things, I wrote about the Stoic idea that some things are up to us and most things aren’t. It applies here too.
You can’t control whether your grown kids come home, whose turn it is with which family, or an empty chair that’s there for reasons no one chose. What you can control is the welcome you offer, the plans you make for yourself, and how much meaning you give the day.
So ask yourself one question: What part of this is actually mine? Then put your energy there, and let the rest go.
Make a plan for the days in between
If your holiday is smaller this year, the hardest part may not be the day itself. It’s the long weekend around it, when everyone else seems to be gathered somewhere.
Plan something for those days on purpose. A book you’ve been saving. A day trip. A meal out. An afternoon with a friend. Small things count. The ideas in 4 simple ways to recharge from midlife burnout work just as well on a holiday weekend that feels too open. And so does looking for the small, good moments I wrote about in Joy in Midlife: It’s Everywhere If You Take Time to Look.
If it still feels hard, that’s OK
Some changes are welcome. Some are bittersweet. Some just hurt. A new shape doesn’t mean you have to love it right away, and a lovely new tradition doesn’t erase missing the old one.
You can be proud of your grown kids and miss them at the same time. You can enjoy a smaller table and still feel the size of the old one. Both are true. I wrote more about this in Celebrations: When It’s About More Than the Celebrating, about the moments that don’t look the way we pictured.
Give yourself the same patience you’d give a friend. Midlife is full of turning points like this one. As I wrote in How to Reinvent Your Life Without Starting Over, we don’t have to throw out who we’ve been to make room for what’s next. The same is true for our traditions.
Three questions to start with this week
Before the holiday arrives, sit down with a cup of coffee and answer these:
- What has changed about my family since the holidays I remember most?
- What one tradition do I want to keep, no matter what?
- What’s one new thing I’d like to try this year?
Write down your answers. Share them with your partner or your grown kids if you’d like. You may find they’ve been wondering the same things.
Your family, your holidays, your shape
Families aren’t fixed. They grow and shrink and stretch across time zones. They add people we never expected and lose people we never wanted to let go. That’s not a failure of the holidays. It’s what a long life looks like.
This year, instead of trying to recreate the past, try building a holiday around the family you have now. It might be smaller. It might be on a Saturday. It might involve friends, brunch, or a walk in the cold. And it might turn out to be the start of something you’ll love.
Want help deciding what’s worth your energy this season? Get Your Simple Season, my free guide to a calmer, fuller holiday.
Shopping for grown kids this year? My Holiday Gift Guide has a whole section for them, full of useful, lasting things for their first real kitchen.